Best Boutique Hotels in The Bahamas

Pineapple Fields

If you’re dreaming of staying steps from a postcard-perfect beach, Pineapple Fields delivers. It sits right across from French Leave Beach, known for its calm, clear waters and great snorkeling. This boutique-style stay offers comfort, privacy, and easy access to nature.

Each suite feels more like a relaxed home than a hotel room, featuring full kitchens, spacious verandas, and tropical garden views. But what truly sets this place apart is its effortless connection to the best of Eleuthera.

Don’t miss a stroll through the lush botanical gardens or a dip in the serene pool area, framed by palms and flowers. Whether you’re snorkeling, savoring a cold Kalik at sunset, or just soaking in the island breeze, you’re going to love your stay.

Good to know: The resort’s botanical garden includes a wooden lookout tower with panoramic views of the island, and the working farm blends seamlessly into the tropical landscaping.

What about the Location?

Right next door, you’ll find Tippy’s, a beloved beachfront restaurant known for its live music and fresh, island-inspired cuisine. Within minutes, you can also reach the Potlatch Club, Levy’s Preserve, and Governor’s Harbour.

The Pilot House

The Pilot House sits between two beaches in Rock Sound, capturing the quiet soul of Eleuthera while giving you easy access to its raw beauty. What makes it different? Karen hosts the place, and she’s not just welcoming—she goes the extra mile. Karen offers insider tips and makes sure you feel right at home.

The property feels private yet connected. The house itself is cozy, clean, and thoughtfully decorated, with large windows that pull the outside in. This place isn’t resort-style — that means no noise and no crowds. You’ll have Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a peaceful patio to sip your morning coffee or stargaze at night.

Good to know: Though nightlife is limited, that’s kind of the point. Come here for the peace, the nature, and the warm, easy rhythm of local life.

What about the Location?

Just as the name suggests, it’s a great base for exploring. From here, you’re a short drive to markets, eateries, and hidden beaches. And thanks to its position between the Atlantic and Caribbean sides, you can enjoy both sunrise swims and sunset walks without ever straying far. This neighborhood balances sleepy island charm with small-town convenience.

French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection

French Leave Resort is one of the few luxury spots in Eleuthera that combine marina access with hilltop ocean views. Whether you arrive by land or sea, you’re in for something special. Tucked along the edge of the Caribbean’s shimmering waters, each villa welcomes you with a private veranda overlooking Governor’s Harbour—offering front-row views of dreamy sunsets and anchored sailboats.

This boutique resort belongs to Marriott’s Autograph Collection, but it doesn’t feel like a chain. Instead, it radiates charm and intention. That means: hand-laid stone pathways, personalized service, and an on-site restaurant.

What about the Location?

You’ll find the resort in Governor’s Harbour, the historical and cultural heart of Eleuthera. This charming town features colonial architecture, a peaceful atmosphere, and a growing selection of restaurants and shops within walking or short driving distance. It’s ideal for travelers who crave a blend of tranquility and local flavor, no crowds, just colorful island life at its best.

Eleuthera Retreat – Private Villa & Cottages on pink sand beachfront

There’s something undeniably magical about waking up just a one-minute walk from one of the Bahamas’ most beautiful pink-tinted beaches. At Eleuthera Retreat, you live in a paradise, even if just for a few unforgettable days.

This private villa and its cozy cottages blend luxury with the warmth of a home. You’ll find fully equipped kitchens, breezy verandas, and thoughtful touches that make the stay feel personal.

But what really sets this spot apart is the owner. He offers fresh bakery bread on request, a charming and delicious touch you won’t find in your average beachfront rental.

Good to know: Don’t forget to bring efficient mosquito repellent.

What about the Location?

You’ll find this peaceful hideaway in the neighborhood of North Palmetto Point, a gem on Eleuthera Island known for its slow pace, friendly locals, and postcard-worthy scenery. While you feel tucked away from the world, several great local restaurants are just a short drive away for when you’re in the mood to dine out.

Tiamo Resort

Tiamo Resort runs almost entirely on solar power, offering travelers a rare mix of barefoot luxury and eco-conscious living. Nestled on South Andros Island, this resort delivers that off-the-grid feel without compromising on comfort. You’ll arrive by boat or seaplane, which instantly sets the tone for a stay that’s far removed from crowds and noise.

The resort features beachfront bungalows and elevated treehouses, each blending Caribbean charm with modern elegance. You’ll have outdoor showers, private pools, and hammocks swaying under palm trees.

The property also includes a small but well-equipped fitness center and a cozy library for downtime.

Food is another standout here. The on-site restaurant serves fresh, local cuisine with a gourmet twist, many ingredients are sourced from nearby farms or the surrounding sea. And if you’re into sustainability, you’ll appreciate their eco-resort practices, from water conservation systems to biodegradable products.

Good to know: Guests can dive into the turquoise waters right off the beach, snorkel vibrant coral reefs, or explore nearby mangroves by kayak.

What about the Location?

Located on the unspoiled shores of South Andros Island. This is the least developed of the Bahamian islands, known for its blue holes, lush mangroves, and thriving coral reefs. With no roads leading to the property, the only way in is by boat or seaplane. There are no nearby restaurants or bars you can walk to. No nightlife in the typical sense.

Paradise Bay Bahamas

Paradise Bay Bahamas is where travelers go to enjoy peace, simplicity, and a genuinely local experience. This small beachfront property sits on Great Exuma, offering colorful private bungalows just a few steps from the ocean. It offers a relaxed and quiet vibe, making it a great option for couples or anyone wanting to disconnect for a few days.

Each bungalow includes a kitchenette, air conditioning, and a private patio. Daily housekeeping keeps things tidy, and there’s an on-site restaurant, La Fourchette, known for its French-Caribbean fusion and laid-back setting.

If you’re up for some activity, kayak and paddleboard rentals are available (for an extra cost), and the calm waters in front of the property are ideal for it. The beach is clean, uncrowded, and often feels like your own private stretch of sand.

What about the Location?

Paradise Bay is close enough to the airport and George Town to be convenient, but far enough to offer true quiet.

Coral Sands Inn & Cottages

Coral Sands blends the charm of a bed and breakfast with the comfort of a boutique resort. Tucked along the iconic pink sand shores of Harbour Island, this reimagined gem delivers a relaxed, upscale stay that keeps guests coming back.

The property recently underwent a refresh, adding a modern feel without losing its character. Expect clean, stylish rooms with a touch of island flair. You can choose between a beachfront cottage and a cozy inn room; either way, the experience stays personal.

You’ll have direct access to the famous pink sand beach. The on-site restaurant serves fresh Bahamian cuisine daily, and the beach bar mixes up solid cocktails, perfect for sunset.

Good to know: Coral Sands has one of the most photographed staircases on the island. It leads straight from the cottages to the beach. Many guests say it’s the best-kept secret spot for sunrise photos.

What about the Location?

Location-wise, you're right on the edge of Dunmore Town. Restaurants, cute shops, and golf cart rentals are all within a quick ride. You won’t need a car here, just flip-flops and maybe a straw hat.

Ocean West Boutique Hotel

Ocean West Boutique Hotel offers a peaceful and elegant escape just five minutes from Lynden Pindling International Airport, making it ideal for both quick getaways and long, relaxing stays in Nassau. Perched on a hill overlooking the ocean, the hotel stands out with its colonial-style architecture, manicured gardens, and a calm, grown-up atmosphere.

This small property offers spacious, clean, and stylish rooms, with high ceilings, antique-style furniture, crisp linens, and marble bathrooms. Many rooms come with balconies offering panoramic ocean views.

One major highlight is the location. While it’s close to the airport, the hotel feels tucked away from the city buzz. Just know, it’s a bit of a walk down (and back up) the hill to reach the main road, so pack comfy shoes or plan for quick taxi rides.

Though the hotel doesn’t have an in-house restaurant, several dining options are nearby, and the staff gladly assists with recommendations or reservations. For breakfast or a drink, the lounge area and poolside patio offer a relaxing spot to start or end your day.

Bear in mind that the vibe here is calm and adult-oriented. It’s ideal for solo travelers, couples, and business guests.

Good to know: There's private airport transport available, making arrival and departure totally hassle-free.

What about the Location?

Pink Sands Resort

Pink Sands Resort gives one of the most iconic beach views in the Bahamas. Located directly on Harbour Island’s famous pink sand beach, this boutique hotel draws travelers looking for top-tier comfort and calm, far from the tourist crowds.

The resort features 29 private cottages and villas, each tucked into lush gardens or directly facing the ocean. Interiors are clean, beachy, and timeless. But the highlight? The pink sand beach! The sand gets its soft pink color from crushed coral, and it stretches over three miles. It’s wide, quiet, and swimmable year-round. Most rooms come with beach chairs and umbrellas already set up, and the on-site team provides towels, drinks, and water gear.

For dining, the Malcolm 51 restaurant offers a Caribbean-influenced menu with plenty of fresh seafood, house-made pasta, and tropical ingredients. There’s also a beachfront bar serving light bites and cocktails with a view.

Good to know: Guests can go horseback riding directly on the beach, arranged through local partners. The resort also offers tennis courts, paddleboards, fishing excursions, and in-room massages on request.

What about the Location?

The location is unbeatable, right on the edge of Harbour Island’s most photogenic stretch. You’re a short walk or golf cart ride from Dunmore Town, known for its pastel cottages, laid-back restaurants, and local boutiques. Water taxis from North Eleuthera take just 10 minutes, and the hotel assists with transfers from the airport.

The Cove Eleuthera

The Cove Eleuthera is one of the most sought-after boutique hotels in the Bahamas, and for good reason. With two private beaches, modern oceanfront villas, and personal service that gets rave reviews, this property delivers a true island escape with every detail handled.

The hotel has just 29 rooms, so the atmosphere stays quiet and exclusive. The design blends clean, contemporary lines with warm island touches. Rooms open right onto the sand or gardens, and many come with direct ocean views.

What makes The Cove different is the setting. You get access to not just one, but two private beaches, one with soft white sand and calm swimming, the other ideal for snorkeling. The water is crystal clear. Paddleboards and kayaks are available for guest use, and staff can help set up boat tours, snorkel trips, or inland adventures across Eleuthera.

The onsite restaurant, Freedom, offers fresh seafood, sushi, and international dishes. Meals are served in an open-air setting with ocean views. There’s also a bar positioned on a cliff between the two beaches, perfect for catching the sunset with a cocktail in hand.

The resort offers a coral restoration experience. Guests can snorkel out to a live coral nursery and learn how the hotel is helping to protect the reef. It’s hands-on, guided, and worth the time.

Good to know: Pack reef-safe sunscreen, and note that there are no large resorts or chains nearby, just local spots and small villages.

What about the Location?

The Cove is located in Gregory Town, Eleuthera, about a 45-minute drive from North Eleuthera Airport. The hotel provides private transport or can help arrange a rental car. The area is quiet and remote, so it’s best for travelers who want peace and natural beauty, not nightlife.